The University of Maine student newspaper since 1875
home
Thursday, Feb. 2, 1 a.m.
Opinion

Op-Ed: Give tithes for anti-marriage equality TV ads

Over the past month, Maine Catholic churches all over the state have sent out collection baskets to help fund an ad campaign against the legalization of gay marriage.

The church has grossly overstepped its boundaries as religious advisors. Churches are pressuring their parishes to get involved in a political squabble that has nothing to do with God and everything to do with the church’s political agenda. Parish members will be granted their chance to oppose gay marriage on ballots in November.

Pushing a parish one way or another on any political issue is insulting to its intelligence. Shouldn’t godly people be able to distinguish right and wrong for themselves? I see no justified reason whatsoever in the archdiocese’s request for aid from people who trust them and are inclined to do as they say.

Hypothetical scenario: I’m sitting in church. The priest gives an impassioned speech about how homosexuality is wrong in accordance with the Bible. There is no standing ovation, but it’s clear the parish majority is in agreement. A collection basket labeled “yes on Prop. 1” is passed around. As the basket travels down the pews, nearly everyone drops some bills into the basket. The basket comes to me. Though it doesn’t say “put your money in the basket because you love Jesus,” the message is clear.

Let’s pretend I’ve never really stood up for myself; I’ve drifted along in life making as few decisions as possible. I don’t want the basket to linger and the elderly woman to my left is looking at me with expectancy. I drop a $5 bill into the basket. I guess I can do without my usual Subway for lunch today. I am relieved, and the basket moves on. In 10 minutes I have forgotten the event.

My hypothetical siuation may be ludicrous. Maybe everyone who goes to church has very clearly defined self value and would never give their priest sway over their thoughts. Maybe I’m going to hell for intending to vote “no” on Proposition 1. Whatever the case, I will never allow another human being to tell me that they speak with God’s divine voice.

If the universe really is ruled by a big male animal sitting on a throne in the sky, I would venture to guess he has more prominent concerns than same-sex couples receiving the personal and political benefits of marriage.

Even if God does nothing but breathe fire and brimstone due to girls kissing girls, the Catholic Church itself has a more immediate concern: survival. More churches and Catholic schools are closing every year; priests are about as abundant as four leaf clovers and convents seem to have all slipped into Narnia. Papa Pope might want to put some money away just in case, because I think Obama’s bail bucket has been stolen by Wall Street.

I implore all churchgoers: Spend your money on something more substantial than an ad campaign designed to drive a wedge between people who love each other. Buying a Playboy magazine would be more virtuous. The last time I checked, homosexuals were still homo sapiens and are promised the same freedoms as the rest of the country. Said freedoms include life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. These things were first engraved in our national consciousness when we declared our independence from Britain.

To quote the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.” The archdiocese would do well to remember this. Considering some of the vehement anti-Catholic sentiment during our history, they may owe their ability to exist in the U.S. to this document.

Daniel Bowman is not dropping any money in the tithe plate this Sunday.

  • 1equalityUSA

    “Anyone who knows history, particularly the history of Europe, will, I think, recognize that the domination of education or of government by any one particular religious faith is never a happy arrangement for the people.” (Eleanor Roosevelt)

    If religion should be the standard to which every American is subject, then which religion? In the future, if the world’s second largest religion, the Islamic religion, is favored and the population in the Islamic community grows substantially higher, should Americans then be subject to the concepts and laws of that particular religion? If religion comes down to a vote, to which religion should the laws of the land ascribe? Buddhism? Taoism? Jefferson was so wise. Separation of church and state is good for believers and non-believers alike.

  • 1equalityUSA

    Who are you to judge your Master’s servant?

    How dare individuals put my Constitutional rights up for a vote! If we are not given equal status in this country, then our taxes should be prorated to reflect this. We now look back at church justified racial bans with eyebrows raised; this issue will be seen in much the same way, given time. God will judge me on my earthly works, not men. Any church leader throwing money into a political rat-race doesn’t understand that it is the Word that transforms hearts, not mere political laws, vulnerable to being overturned. Trust the leadership role of your Father and transform hearts with love, patience, and sound Wisdom. Lobbying Christ into law is an inferior use of the Word of God and will fail. Transformation requires cooperation. Do you have that much faith in propositions? Do you have Faith? Is this a money generator for you? Examine your motives, church leaders, and ask if the teachings of Jesus will be fruitful in political realms. I question the faith of any Church leader who wallows in politics in order to plant spiritual seeds. It’s futility. It’s striving for the wind and feeding on it. It’s time to teach transformative Word, let Wisdom prevail, and leave politics to the world. You’ll honor the God for whom you so often speak, changing hearts in a more permanent fashion. People are being driven away from the message. Is that wise?

  • 1equalityUSA

    Jesus never talked about gays, nor are gays mentioned in the Ten Commandments, nor in the Summary of the Law. No prophet expounds upon gays. It really wasn’t that concerning in early churches. Being judgmental is the worse offense. That’s spoken of so often that it would seem to be the more important lesson for us.
    I understand Catholics’ concern. Jesus must not have shared this concern, as He never spoke about gays.
    Much has been learned about how the human psyche and physiological effects can alter one’s sexuality. Perhaps, all knowing Jesus was so quiet about this subject because He saw what rabbinical Paul (Saul) couldn’t see. People have always been gay and always will be. It’s not unusual. When we leave these temporal bodies, flesh will cease, gender will cease, the only things we will have will be a spirit, defined by how we treated others. Love endures. You’ve been commanded to love, not point fingers in judgment.

  • Lynn

    More power to you Daniel Bowman!

  • FlexSF

    I can’t believe you contributed $5 because of an evil gaze from a religious zealot next to you. Your $5 will cause real harm to the intimate lives of the people that you seem to support. It will also facilitate the reckless ignorance espoused by the Catholic, money laundering corporation.

    I would like to see the institution destroyed. May the federal lawsuits against it be a thumb in it’s eyes until it is delivered from it’s blind bigotry!

  • 1equalityUSA

    Everyone talks about how churches, involving themselves in American politics, should not be privy to tax exempt status, but it seems to be becoming even more blatant. How do we stop it?

  • http://armme.wordpress.com labrat

    Mr. Z in your example about the Houlton man that overdosed on xanax and “liquid methadone”….do you mind telling me where the xanax came from? Or does no one bother to find out who gave this person that drug simply because methadone was involved? I mean, in reality the man probably wouldn’t have died if he’d taken either methadone or xanax by themselves…so that means BOTH drugs were equally responsible for his death.

    NO NO wait! Since a drug, by it’s very nature, has no will or fever for killing…I would say the only “thing” responsible for the death was the addiction that drove him to take two medication he knew would kill him!

    The irony is, if this man had been in methadone treatment at a clinic he probably wouldn’t have died…and again isn’t that the whole point? To keep people alive and stable?

  • http://armme.wordpress.com labrat

    sorry wrong article!

  • http://fathermartykurylowicz.blogspot.com/ Fr. Marty Kurylowicz

    I wrote a comment to a news article in the Bangor Daily News about Maine’s Catholic Bishop Malone’s antigay statement, in support of Marriage Equality and challenging the his ignorance about human sexuality and the bible.

    …Same-sex marriage is a dangerous sociological experiment that many of us believe will have negative consequences for society as a whole,” said [Bishop] Malone in the message, according to the Bangor Daily News. “Children need the love of a mother and a father.”


    This statement is cruel and untrue. People against Marriage Equality do not base their public statements on facts either from science or the bible. It is a repeat of the time the Vatican was condemning Galileo, because they insisted that Galileo was going against the bible that it is the sun that revolves around the earth.

    Children need people who are honest and truthful. Children are not safe around people who publicly speak out against Marriage Equality, because in truth these people have had no formal study in human sexuality or the bible and yet they without any intellectual thought speak out and harm innocent people. This is irresponsible adult behavior, which is harmful for children to witness. This has been proven to have “negative consequences” for children, consult developmental psychology.

    With all due respect, it is without a question that Bishop Malone would not be able to pass graduate course exams on human sexuality, sexual orientation, and gender identity or biblical studies. Prove me wrong!!!

    And if Bishop Malone cannot pass these exams today, than before God he needs to publically retract what he said against Marriage Equality. If not, then Bishop Malone needs to go back to the seminary to study moral theology.

    The best for well-being and safety of all children would be if people against Marriage Equality spent their money to academically study human sexuality, sexual orientation, gender identity and the bible. This is what children need the truth. People speaking out on such life and death issues should not speak out of ignorance and fear, thus spreading hatred and violence that indiscriminately is severely harmful to all children.

    The truth will set you free – not ignorance and fear.
    Fr. Marty Kurylowicz
    http://fathermartykurylowicz.blogspot.com/2009/09/maine-bishop-fights-marriage-equality.html

  • 1equalityUSA

    Fr. Marty Kurylowicz,
    Thank you for this very powerful letter. Thanks for taking the time to write these thoughts and publish them. Kindness resonates in your words, as though you stopped a bully in the school yard. Likely, Bishop Malone is too busy counting his newly attained hate dollars to bother reading this. He might even be rolling in it, laughing giddily in the sacristy. Will he be given the same measure of mercy from our Father that he has shown to people here on Earth?

  • antiformal

    Homosexuality doesn’t belong in heaven and it doesn’t belong in the law. God is infallible and states clearly that homosexuality is an abomination that must not be condoned. What are we but a pit of sinners if we do not prohibit such activity?
    We have an obligation to the lord our god to discourage in the most gentile way possible the actions of homosexuals.

  • 1equalityUSA

    Jesus never talked about gays, nor are gays mentioned in the Ten Commandments, nor in the Summary of the Law. No prophet expounds upon gays. It really wasn’t that concerning in early churches. Being judgmental is the worse offense. That’s spoken of so often that it would seem to be the more important lesson for us.
    I understand “antiformal’s” concern. Jesus must not have shared this concern, as He never spoke about gays.
    Much has been learned about how the human psyche and physiological effects can alter one’s sexuality. Perhaps, all knowing Jesus was so quiet about this subject because He saw what rabbinical Paul (Saul) could not see. People have always been gay and always will be. It’s not unusual. When we leave these temporal bodies, flesh will cease, gender will cease, the only thing we will have will be a spirit, defined by how we treated others. Love endures. You’ve been commanded to love, not point fingers in judgment.

  • 1equalityUSA

    Justice denied anywhere diminishes justice everywhere: Martin Luther King, Jr.

    Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man’s character, give him power. — Abraham Lincoln