The University of Maine student newspaper since 1875
home
Thursday, Feb. 9, 1:34 a.m.
CD Reviews | Style & Culture

CD Review: ‘Year of the Black Rainbow’ proves Coheed and Cambria can’t make bad music

The beginning has finally come for Coheed and Cambria.

Eight years after the band kicked off its “Amory Wars” series of concept albums and accompanying comic series with “Second Stage Turbine Blade,” the band’s sonic storyline is finally complete after Tuesday’s release of its prequel album, “Year of the Black Rainbow.”

If that last paragraph meant absolutely nothing to you, don’t worry. One of the perks with a band like Coheed and Cambria — and there are few bands like them — is that you don’t need to understand the sci-fi epic that is the Amory Wars to know they rock in a way few other bands do. 

The unfortunate thing about Coheed’s je ne sais quoi is it doesn’t grab you right away. The first time I listened to “Year of the Black Rainbow,” I told my friends the album was a solid mix of mediocre and awesome. Both “The Broken” and “Here We Are Juggernaut,” the album’s singles, perfectly demonstrated everything great about Coheed and Cambria: the frolicking basslines, the prog-a-riffic guitar tracks and Claudio Sanchez’s ethereal vocal melodies. The rest sort of fell flat.

But, being the super-fan I am and remembering similar experiences with the great departure that was “Good Apollo I,” I gave the album a couple more shots. After about three full play-throughs, I couldn’t stop hitting “repeat all” on iTunes.

In many respects, “Year of the Black Rainbow” is a sort of homecoming for Coheed and Cambria. The band’s release of “Good Apollo, I’m Burning Star IV, Volume One: From Fear Through the Eyes of Madness” in 2005 marked a departure from the pop-punk roots that made the band a favorite on Warped Tour and propelled them to fame on the backs of their first two albums. That heavier, weirder side carried them through their last two albums.

But “Year of the Black Rainbow” has very little of the progressive rock feel of the “Good Apollo” albums; if anything, it is a push back to the glory that was “In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth,” the album that popelled Coheed over the edge into mainstream success.

Aside from the two singles, for which much ink has already been spilled, the best track on the album has got to be “World of Lines.” The track’s chorus is so catchy I found myself singing along before I even knew the words. It didn’t matter that I was faking it; the song just demanded audience participation.

The track getting a whole lot of attention in the fanverse is “Far.” All of Coheed’s albums have at least one ballad-esque track, and this is it for “Year of the Black Rainbow.” The song is melancholy without being too over-the-top. According to the DVD that came with the album, drummer Chris Pennie experimented with a drumkit made of trashcans, and this song sounds like it features the garbage-kit. It’s interesting, but not particularly compelling, and may be the weakest track on the otherwise stellar album.

It bears mention the album was co-produced by Joe Baressi and Atticus Ross. Normally I wouldn’t mention production in a review, but Ross also produced Nine Inch Nails’ “With Teeth” and “Year Zero,” and his contribution to the album’s overall soundscape is evident in the gritty, grimy feel of a good chunk of the album’s tracks. The distortion level leaves the music sounding outright sludgy at times — new territory for Coheed and Cambria —and I can’t help but think it’s all thanks to Ross.

Regardless of who deserves ultimate praise for the album, “Year of the Black Rainbow” is a solid release from a band that doesn’t know how to put out anything but good music.

Grade: B+

  • Graham

    This review is exactly how I felt about the album. I was extremely excited about its release and then when it came out I was slightly disappointed because it was not as good as I had hoped. I like a couple songs (Far, Here We Are Juggernaut, Pearl of the Stars) but wasn’t too thrilled about the rest of the album.

    Like many albums in the past, not just Coheed, it has required multiple listenings to fully appreciate the music. Now I love the whole album, especially the ones mentioned above plus The Black Rainbow, Guns of Summer, World of Lines and my favorite of the album, Made of Nothing.

  • Steve Tegan

    I agree with Graham, it seemed as if they rushed the process somehow, and many of the tracks seemed to be washed out in reverb; the guitars seemed muddy and indistinct at times. I should hope that they take all the time necessary to compose a better follow-up next time.

  • Sydney

    YOTBR is amazing, but I agree with Tegan…it’s just not the same when you can’t tell the instruments from each other. That was always one of my favorite aspects of CO&CA–the creative instrumentation. Oh well, I’m sure there will be new music in the future. Until then, I can allow my face to melt with Welcome Home and Delirium Trigger, yes?

  • Alexander

    I’ve been a Co&Ca fan since its early days, i’m from Ecuador in south-america, and let me tell you something good music it’s hardly found over here,Im really dissapointed with YOTBR, i know that its might take several replays to understand this complicated album, but the fact is that despite of its originality a creativity its extremely difficult to understand the panaromic soundscape the album have, and thats a problem comparing to old Co&Ca albums in which you can actually go along with the music easily understanding the guitars, bass, drums, keyboard, choruses,etc. The thing is that listeners doesnt requiered to have a special hearing skills to understand music, if the music sounds good and you can understand everythig then you are in the right path if it doesnt well you might want to check your mix man,,,YOTBR loud bass, messy guitar dist, a whole bunch of analog reverbs that simply doesnt match with Co&Ca style, hopefully they keep on rockin and creating amazing music but they’ll need to check their mix more patiently and dont rush…